Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 2 years later...

Why did ETS choose to use low floor Light rail vehicles and not high floor light rail vehicles for this line? When does ETS hope to start building the Mill Woods to City Centre LRT line?

Cheaper costs (building and maintenance), plus access for wheelchairs and the disabled. I used to say the EXACT same thing when discussing plans for the LRT in Winnipeg and got shut down fast. :P

As for building it, that I'd have no idea. Gonna take Martins post and start doing some Googling.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Cheaper costs (building and maintenance), plus access for wheelchairs and the disabled.

Because obviously the current system doesn't have access for wheelchairs and the disabled :P

No the real reasoning is a bunch of salesman from Ireland came in and sold them on the idea. Being ETS, there were a few public "consultation" meetings which explained how they were arbitrarily going with this system whether anyone likes it or not. Mayor Mandel's aversion to sticking with the original plans for West LRT (87th ave via University... couldn't do that as it would run right through the backyards of all of his rich voting clientele who obviously don't use transit) provided additional justification; this is easier to shoehorn into Stony Plain Road than conventional LRT.

Link to post
Share on other sites

When Edmonton chose high-floor light rail, way back in 1974, low floor light rail didn't exist and since they were already branching into the [North American] unknown by choosing light rail, I don't think their innovative risk-taking can be over-estimated. The only rapid transit examples in North America to draw on were heavy rail. As a result Edmonton's light rail has several heavy rail characteristics (high platforms, subway tunnel, mezzanine levels in stations, no street-running, and off-board fare collection, to name a few).

Fast forward four decades, and there are light rail systems in operation or under construction all over North America. Within a decade or two of Edmonton opening the typical design standard is now low-floor, with low-level platforms. So for Edmonton (and Calgary) the question is whether or not to carry forward with what is now a cumbersome design (stations are bigger and more expensive, cars are not as off-the-shelf) because it integrates with what exists, or to develop a more standard second design and live without interoperability.

London did it, changing train profiles between large- and small-bore tubes. New York too, with different widths for IRT and IND-BMT trains. Toronto chose standard gauge for "Transit City" instead of the Toronto-gauge of the existing streetcar network. I understand Calgary is leaning towards low-floor for the Centre Street and/or Southeast line(s).

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 months later...
  • 3 months later...
  • 2 years later...

With the gong show of Bomardier`s heavily delayed delivery of Flexcity cars to TTC is there any chance of ETS being negatively effected with implementation of this line? Seems like the Toronto order is late to such a point that the "in service" date of 2020 may become the initial receiving timeline of cars? I hope this is not the case and Bombardier steps it up.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's in the consortiums best interest for Bombardier to complete on time. Apparently the consortium can replace Bombardier (or anyone else) if they fail to meet expectations.

I don't know how that would play out given lead times for LRV's, but, I guess Bombardier can't get their act together in the next year or so, I suspect there could be enough time to bring someone else on board.

Anyways, I think the real measure is not the TTC deliveries but Bombardier deliveries for other new projects, like Waterloo and Metrolinx LRT projects in Toronto.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 years later...
On 6/10/2016 at 10:01 PM, M. Parsons said:

It's in the consortiums best interest for Bombardier to complete on time. Apparently the consortium can replace Bombardier (or anyone else) if they fail to meet expectations.

I don't know how that would play out given lead times for LRV's, but, I guess Bombardier can't get their act together in the next year or so, I suspect there could be enough time to bring someone else on board.

Anyways, I think the real measure is not the TTC deliveries but Bombardier deliveries for other new projects, like Waterloo and Metrolinx LRT projects in Toronto.

I mean, it's been a year and a half and only one has been delivered

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, M. Parsons said:

It's been more like 6 months and it's sitting inside a tent at the Gerry Wright facility. There is literally no where to put any new cars yet. 

I meant a year and a half since the qouted comment was posted. When will the new carbarns be built?

Edited by Jaymaud0804
Fat fingers
Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Jaymaud0804 said:

I meant a year and a half since the qouted comment was posted. When will the new carbarns be built?

They are already partially built. You can see this page for some photos from October 2018: http://transedlrt.ca/gallery/omf-progress-photos/

These photos are from April 2018: http://transedlrt.ca/gallery/area-7-gerry-wright-omf/

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 11 months later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 2 months later...
  • 5 months later...

Way to go TransEd. 

These guys have been a joke when it comes to concrete work. We've watched them jackhammer out track bed. The entire Whitemud Bridge had to be rebuilt before it was even put in place due to poor concrete work, and now they are replacing 2, possibly 3 segments of the elevated guideway because of some build quality issues.

Overnight Wagner Road Closure

Noise, Notice, Vehicle

October 9, 2020 – Wagner Road will be closed overnight between 75 Street and 80 Street on October 19, 22, 24 and 27. Closures will take place between 9:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. each night while TransEd crews replace two elevated spans on the Valley Line LRT.  The closure also impacts 75 Street north and southbound, which will briefly close at Wagner Road for equipment access.

We were pretty sure that this was a new guideway section being built, and there's another one that they started working on recently by 75 St.

DSC09531.thumb.jpg.5e89e0d2c75c542d159fc4408896de7c.jpgDSC09527.thumb.jpg.ddc75154601fd773eb9066562df4cb26.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, M. Parsons said:

Way to go TransEd. 

These guys have been a joke when it comes to concrete work. We've watched them jackhammer out track bed. The entire Whitemud Bridge had to be rebuilt before it was even put in place due to poor concrete work, and now they are replacing 2, possibly 3 segments of the elevated guideway because of some build quality issues.

oh ffs. No bloody wonder why my regulars are getting so pissed off with the constant concrete work near Avonmore. TransEd needs to just contract this crap out and be done with it

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, M. Parsons said:

Way to go TransEd. 

These guys have been a joke when it comes to concrete work. We've watched them jackhammer out track bed. The entire Whitemud Bridge had to be rebuilt before it was even put in place due to poor concrete work, and now they are replacing 2, possibly 3 segments of the elevated guideway because of some build quality issues.

Just curious - is TransEd using union workers? Or nickel and diming it out en masse, with literally anyone they can find? If it was union work, there's no way that much mistakes would've happened, to delay things on Edmontons new LRT. That or mayve hiring some more QA/QC's? 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/9/2020 at 6:07 PM, M. Parsons said:

now they are replacing 2, possibly 3 segments of the elevated guideway because of some build quality issues.

Yep, 3 segments. Second notification has been posted.

Full Closure of 75 Street – Wagner Road to McIntyre Road

Noise, Notice, Sidewalk, Vehicle

October 16, 2020 – Starting on or around November 6, crews will be replacing an elevated span on the Valley Line LRT.  To accommodate this work, 75 Street will be closed between Wagner Road and McIntyre Road from 9:00 p.m. Friday, November 6 and reopen at 6:00 a.m. Monday, November 9.

To accommodate this work, the public will be impacted in the following areas:

  • Full closure of 75 Street between Wagner Road and McIntyre Road.
  • Pedestrian access will be maintained.

Should the activities not be completed over this weekend, for reasons including but not limited to inclement weather, the weekend of November 13 will serve as the contingency date. 

During this time please watch for, and follow, all traffic detours and direction of construction personnel.

TransEd is committed to following all City of Edmonton bylaws and regulations and has obtained an overnight roadwork permit so that work can take place during nighttime hours in order to minimize major daytime traffic disruptions. *City of Edmonton Bylaw C14600.

We ask for your understanding and patience as construction progresses.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...